Best Hotels in Shelter Island on the Beach
View all photos
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
Located within a 10-minute drive of Menhadden Lane Beach, the 5-bedroom Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool! Villa has an outdoor swimming pool and is ideal for up to 8 guests.
Mashomack Preserve is 2.4 km from the property, while East Hampton is 16 km away.
Situated approximately 15 minutes' drive from Shelter Island Presbyterian Church, this Shelter Island holiday home is popular destination for both worshippers and tourists.
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool! Villa is furnished with a writing desk, as well as Wi-Fi and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. Guests can also enjoy a balcony or in-room facilities like an ironing set and air conditioning. The Shelter Island property comes with a bathroom with a spa bathtub and a separate toilet. Hair dryers and bath sheets are included to enhance your comfort.
View all photos
From
334$/night
The Pridwin Hotel
Offering a sunbathing terrace and a golf course, and views of the sea, The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island is located about 4 km from Nova Constellatio Gallery. Offering a seafood menu in an American restaurant along with a steam room and a sauna onsite, the hotel boasts a location in a rural area.
This 4-star hotel has a waterfront setting 10 minutes' drive from Greenport Antique Carousel. The Pridwin is 3.5 km from Southold Bay and 143 km from New York.
The private beach is approximately 5 minutes' walk away. The nearby cultural experience includes Railroad Museum of Long Island, which is 3.4 km away.
A terrace and a deck are included in the rooms for guests' convenience. The rooms also feature a king-size bed.
An outdoor swimming pool and a fitness club will help you stay healthy. This accommodation offers sport activities, such as lawn tennis, ping-pong, and billiard.
View all photos
From
149$/night
Taber Inn
Offering air-conditioned rooms and Wi-Fi throughout the property, the 3-star Taber Inn Mystic is a mere 1.9 km from the waterfront gallery "Mystic Museum of Art" and a 9-minute stroll from the oceanfront Williams Beach Park. Located about a 25-minute walk from the recreated 19th-century coastal village "Mystic Seaport Museum", this inn offers views of the garden and a swimming pool.
The centre of Mystic can be reached within a 15-minute walk, and natural attractions like Esker Point Beach are 4.7 km away. The Taber Mystic places you within a 700-metre distance of Williams Beach.
Also, Willams Beach Park is situated around 5 minutes' walk away. The area offers shopping experiences such as Olde Mistick Village Shopping Mall, which is 2.9 km from this Mystic hotel.
The rooms at the accommodation have air conditioning and soundproof walls. Some of them comprise a balcony and a sitting area, appointed with a writing desk. The rooms come with a separate bathroom. For more comfort, a shower cap and bath sheets, along with a spa bathtub, are provided.
Taber Inn features a sunbathing terrace, a picnic area, and a golf course, as well as a fitness centre located on-site. The property offers activities such as hiking, cycling, and fisheries.
Luxury Beachfront Hotels in Shelter Island
View all photos
From
157$/night
Montauk Manor
The smoke-free Montauk Manor Hotel, situated approximately 4 km from Lake Montauk, proudly provides guests with 3 outdoor tennis courts. This 5-star hotel lies around 10 minutes' drive from the large Ditch Plains Beach, and offers an à la carte restaurant and an indoor pool onsite.
The centre of Montauk can be reached in 20 minutes' walk of the hotel, and such cultural venues as Second House Museum are 3.6 km away. You'll find Saint Therese of Lisieux Church about 20 minutes on foot from the Manor Montauk.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to Montauk Downs State Park, situated 2.3 km away. Feel in total harmony with nature by visiting Camp Hero State Park, nearly a 25-minute walk from the property.
Montauk Manor Hotel has 96 rooms with a dining area and a kitchen. High-speed internet and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels along with coffee/tea making machines are provided. This Montauk hotel also features a freezer, a toaster, and kitchenware. Equipped with a bidet, a separate toilet, and a shower/bath combination, the spacious bathrooms have hairdryers and towels.
Along with a fitness centre, this accommodation also features a hot tub and a sauna. A selection of sport activities, provided by the Manor, include lawn tennis and cycling. Those on a business trip will benefit from a computer workstation and a photocopy machine provided on site.
View all photos
From
119$/night
Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods
The 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods Preston is nestled 4.7 km from Ledyard Up-Down Sawmill History Museum, offering 154 rooms and featuring a casino, a shared lounge, and a library.
The ascending trails "Lantern Hill" is nearly 10 minutes away by car, and Middletown is 58 km from the hotel.
This Preston inn is 2.5 km from the foxwoods Resort casino "Festival Buffet".
Some rooms at the Hilton Garden Inn are fitted with ironing facilities and air conditioning, and such self-catering options as tea and coffee-making facilities. Guests can also use a shower, along with such amenities as a hairdryer.
There is an indoor pool with a hot tub for an enjoyable stay. Keeping fit at this hotel is convenient thanks to an exercise room that offers fitness classes.
View all photos
From
155$/night
Old Town Inn
Offering a sundeck and a picnic area, and views of the garden, the comfortable Old Town Inn New Shoreham is located 3.5 km from Block Island beaches. There is a car park on site and Wi-Fi in public areas.
The centre of New Shoreham can be reached in 10 minutes' walk of this hotel, and such cultural venues as Island Free Library are nearly 5 minutes' drive away. Mansion Beach is 3.6 km from the Old Town Inn in New Shoreham.
Guests might as well enjoy proximity to Veterans Park, situated approximately 5 minutes away by car. There is Mohegan Bluffs Cliff 2.8 km from this New Shoreham hotel.
The rooms have private bathrooms with a walk-in shower and a separate toilet. Also, the property features parquet flooring.
If you like an active lifestyle, hiking and badminton are available on site. The presence of a tennis court ensures guests an active stay at this hotel.
5 Star Hotels in Shelter Island on the Beach
View all photos
From
130$/night
Montauk Blue Hotel
Nestled around a 5-minute walk from Fort Pond, the 3-star Montauk Blue Hotel offers a sundeck, a picnic area, and a golf course. Located a mere 1.8 km from Lake Montauk, the resort offers views of the sea and a swimming pool.
This beachfront hotel is 10 minutes by car from Hither Hills and just steps from Montauk bus stop. Sunset Surf Shack is 450 metres from the Montauk Blue, while the celebrated Ditch Plains Beach is 2.7 km away.
Guests might as well visit Fort Pond Fishing Access, which is about 5 minutes' drive away. This accommodation also stands in close proximity to Camp Hero State Park.
The hotel offers rooms with a balcony and a sitting area featuring air conditioning, along with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels.
Beach facilities at this property include deck chairs, umbrellas, and towels.
View all photos
From
144$/night
Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino
Positioned within 6 km of the expansive Mashantucket Pequot Museum and Research Center and around a 10-minute drive from Long Pond, the 3-star boutique Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino North Stonington presents two jacuzzis. This North Stonington hotel has an American-style restaurant and a heated indoor pool for its guests.
Located about a 15-minute ride from family attractions like Fox Arcade, the inn is 20 minutes’ walk from North Stonington city centre. Southampton is 59 km from Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino, while North Stonington Congregational Church is 2.9 km away.
Visit Lewis Pond, within 20 minutes' walk of the property, and feel complete harmony with the nature of United States. The hotel stands approximately 2 km from North Stonington Baptist Church, popular with pilgrims and tourists alike.
The Bellissimo North Stonington welcomes guests to 147 rooms fitted with air conditioning as well as a flat-screen TV with cable channels. The bathrooms are equipped with a separate toilet and a shower, along with hairdryers and towels.
The Bellissimo invites guests to have a great time at a casino and a movie theatre. Keeping fit at this hotel is convenient thanks to a fitness centre that offers fitness classes.
View all photos
From
113$/night
Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury
Situated about a 5-minute walk from the 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury, guests can reach Somerset Square Shopping Center in no time. Boasting an indoor pool and a 24-hour fitness center, the inn offers access to the nine-story museum "Connecticut Science Center", which is around 7 km away.
Webb-Deane-Stevens Museum stands nearly 10 minutes away by car, and Riverfront Park is within 25 minutes' walk of this Glastonbury hotel. The Hilton Garden Inn is also 8 km from Trinity College.
Shopping enthusiasts will enjoy being 20 minutes' stroll from Glen Lochen Mall Shopping Center.
The rooms at the hotel have air conditioning. Some of them comprise a kitchenette and a dining area, appointed with a sofa bed and a study desk. Guests can also enjoy street views. Self-catering facilities in an apartment include a kitchen with a microwave, an electric kettle, and refrigerators.
The property’s pool area has a hot tub.
Cheap Hotels on the beach in Shelter Island
View all photos
From
79$/night
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
Providing 67 rooms, the 3-star La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area Hotel Pawcatuck is nestled nearly 5 minutes' walk from Pawcatuck River. This Pawcatuck hotel has a heated pool as well as luggage storage.
The hotel is 2.7 km from Westerly Downtown Historic District, while Westerly Library & Wilcox Park is 2.5 km away. Cultural sights in the area include Living Sharks Museum & Research Center, which is approximately 25 minutes' walk away.
The La Quinta Pawcatuck is 2.6 km from Wilcox Park.
Some rooms provide tea and coffee making facilities as well as a flat-screen TV with satellite channels and a radio to help you enjoy your stay. Some rooms include a private bathroom. They come with a separate toilet and a shower along with such comforts as a hair dryer and towels. Guests can also enjoy views of the street.
At the property, guests can also benefit from fitness classes provided at a fitness centre.
View all photos
From
195$/night
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
Offering an ideal location just off a motorway, the comfortable 3-star Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven Yaphank hotel provides a gift shop and luggage storage for guests' comfort. Boasting a heated pool and a health club, the smoke-free hotel offers access to Southaven County Park, which is about a 10-minute ride away.
This Yaphank hotel is conveniently located 3.9 km from St. John the Theologian Orthodox Church and 2.2 km from the historic Saint Andrew Episcopal Church. The nearby sports attractions include Baseball Heaven, approximately a 15-minute drive from the Home2 Suites Yaphank.
Standing 3.6 km away, Holy Trinity Lutheran Church is a hard-to-miss divine tourist destination.
The air-conditioned rooms comprise a sitting area, and offer a flat-screen TV with satellite channels along with coffee/tea making machines. The bedrooms come with sofa beds.
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven hotel goes the extra mile to provide guests with fitness classes to help them stay fit. Those on a business trip will benefit from conference facilities and a photocopy machine provided on site.
View all photos
From
99$/night
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg
The 3-star Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg is located nearly 25 minutes' walk from Doctor Francis Giuffrida Park, offering 159 rooms, Wi-Fi, and parking. Boasting an indoor pool, this Meriden hotel is nestled 4.7 km from natural attractions like Timberline Park.
Westfield Falls is within 10 minutes' drive of the hotel, while Smith Park is approximately 15 minutes' drive away. Guests can easily reach Meriden Green 4.8 km from the Holiday Inn.
Visit Silver Lake, around 500 metres from the property, and feel complete harmony with the nature of United States. The nearby sports attractions feature Hunter Memorial Golf Course within 2 km of this Meriden hotel.
Some rooms include a kitchenette and a dining area featuring individual climate control and an iron, along with a flat-screen TV with cable channels. Also, they feature tiled flooring. Bathrooms are equipped with a separate toilet and a shower, as well as comforts such as hairdryers and bath sheets. Guests can also enjoy views of the garden.
Beach facilities at this accommodation include beach towels. Keeping fit at the hotel is convenient thanks to a fitness centre that offers fitness classes.
Shelter Island Pet Friendly Beachfront Hotels
View all photos
From
206$/night
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
The 3-star Inn At Harbor Hill Marina Niantic is situated in a beach area of Niantic, about 7 km from Cedar Ridge Golf Course and 19 minutes' walk from Children's Educational Museum of Southeastern Connecticut. A gift shop are available for guests' convenience at this comfortable bed & breakfast, which sits in a historic district.
The hotel has a scenic setting within a few blocks of Niantic Bay Boardwalk. The Inn places you approximately 5 minutes' drive from Hole-in-the-Wall Beach.
The private beach is located 1.1 km away. The area also includes natural sites like Rocky Neck State Park, which are within a 10-minute drive of this accommodation.
A balcony are included in the rooms for guests' convenience. The rooms include views of the ocean.
View all photos
From
109$/night
Winnapaug Inn
The comfortable 3-star Winnapaug Inn Westerly is located within 20 minutes' walk of Misquamicut Fire District Beach and comprises 51 rooms with modern comforts. Featuring an outdoor swimming pool, this Westerly hotel is 2.8 km from natural sights like Dunes Park Beach.
The hotel is near the shopping district of Westerly and around a 10-minute drive from Misquamicut Beach. New Haven is 63 km from Winnapaug Inn, while the summertime Bayview Fun Park is approximately 4 km away.
The private beach is located nearly a 20-minute walk away. The accommodation will also take you to the restored Flying Horse Carousel, which is approximately 7 km away.
For your comfort, the air-conditioned rooms come with air conditioning and soundproof walls. They are furnished with sound-proofed windows, and modern amenities like high-speed internet and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. There is also a private bathroom. A separate toilet and a shower/bath combination, along with hairdryers and bath sheets, are featured in the bathrooms.
Guests can enjoy a sunbathing terrace, a picnic area, and a golf course onsite. There is a fitness centre at the Winnapaug Inn.
View all photos
From
101$/night
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
Located next to the business district of Rocky Hill, the comfortable Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg features 18 holes of golf. Boasting a seasonal outdoor pool and a fitness room, the 3-star historical hotel offers access to Elm Ridge Park, which is nearly 10 minutes' drive away.
Buttolph-Williams House is 3.8 km from this Rocky Hill hotel, while Ferry Park is 2.2 km from this place. The Holiday Inn Express Rocky Hill is also approximately 400 metres from Great Meadow Shopping Center and within 20 minutes' walk of Rocky Hill.
Guests will also appreciate the vicinity to Sunny Crest Park, located just 1.8 km away. The nearby shopping sights include Wethersfield Shopping Plaza Shopping Center, which is around 25 minutes' walk away.
For your comfort, the modern rooms come with blackout drapes and air conditioning. They are furnished with a tiled floor, and modern amenities like an iPod dock and Wi-Fi. The rooms have elegant furniture featuring a writing table and a large work desk. The private bathrooms, fitted with a separate toilet, a shower, and a hydromassage showerhead, also offer hair dryers and towels.
Those on a business trip will benefit from a work desk and a photocopy machine provided on site.
Location
Shelter Island, New York State, United States, 11964
Contact Us